O
Box Elder County
← Community
ZoningCommunity discussion

zoning

Box Elder County

Summary not yet generated for this topic.

Community sentiment

Opposed (2)Concerned (1)

At a glance

Public comments
3
Last 30 days
0

Discussed at 2 meetings in the last 60 days; most recently Oct 7, 2026.

Public comments (29)

OpposedDeanne HardyOct 7, 2026

Expressed disappointment that commissioners did not discuss the constitutionality of zoning private property and argued that general planning and data collection violate constitutional rights.

County Commission - Oct 7, 2026 · 27:17 →
OpposedJanine BielOct 7, 2026

Questioned the commissioners' authority to impose zoning regulations, comparing fees and zoning restrictions to coercion.

County Commission - Oct 7, 2026 · 35:01 →
OpposedDeanna HardySep 2, 2026

Stated further opposition to county zoning, calling central planning a Marxist ideology and challenging the authority of planning commissions.

County Commission - Sep 2, 2026 · 51:23 →
OpposedDeanna HardySep 2, 2026

Opposed agricultural protection areas and county zoning, arguing they violate the U.S. and Utah constitutions.

County Commission - Sep 2, 2026 · 11:11 →
ConcernedVeron MortensenAug 20, 2026

Cautioned that half-acre lots require proper infrastructure and water, and suggested property owners should have options to opt out or use conversion zones.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Aug 20, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveKirt EnrightAug 20, 2026

Expressed relief that the Agricultural Heritage Zone is not as restrictive as he initially feared and appreciated being able to provide input as a landowner.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Aug 20, 2026 · 0:00 →
OpposedDeAnna HardyJul 7, 2026

Expressed concerns about property rights and government overreach regarding agricultural protection areas and historical principles of liberty.

County Commission - Jul 7, 2026 · 21:14 →
OpposedDeAnna HardyApr 22, 2026

Criticized past county tax increases, salary bumps for elected officials, and county ambulance purchases, calling zoning restrictions unconstitutional.

County Commission - Apr 22, 2026 · 1:13:36 →
SupportiveBailey ShafferApr 16, 2026

Supported the AHZ for balancing new neighbors with agricultural preservation so kids can grow up in a rural environment.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveWes PiersonApr 16, 2026

Noted that 80 to 90 percent of local residents favored the Agricultural Heritage Zone as a compromise following the county general plan.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
OpposedJeff MillerApr 16, 2026

Warned that approving the rezone would set a dangerous precedent for the rest of the county and undermine community trust.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
ConcernedJohn HurdApr 16, 2026

Submitted written comments outlining concerns regarding traffic, police and fire protection, water availability, septic tank leaching, and annexation pressures related to the Mantua rezone.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveAlexandria ManningApr 16, 2026

Expressed support for keeping the Agricultural Heritage Zone approved in her neighborhood.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveJay CapenerApr 16, 2026

Spoke as an applicant advocating for agriculture and recognizing the economic multipliers of farming in the county.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveLarry HessApr 16, 2026

Praised the open alfalfa fields and expressed a desire to keep farmland protected from housing developments.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
OpposedGatlin LearApr 16, 2026

Voiced opposition to putting homes on farm ground and stated the community cannot sustain more traffic.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveJake LarsonApr 16, 2026

Highlighted the beauty and productivity of the local farm ground and urged the commission to keep the Agricultural Heritage Zone.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
OpposedJackie SnooksApr 16, 2026

Shared concerns about how unmanaged development alters rural character, increases traffic, and causes water shortages.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveBrent ShafferApr 16, 2026

Spoke as a member of the community steering committee in support of preserving the Agricultural Heritage Zone.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveBryan BinghamApr 16, 2026

Expressed support for following established community rules and building a home on family farm property under current guidelines.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveBrian ShafferApr 16, 2026

Asked the commission to uphold the current Agricultural Heritage Zone and stay consistent with the county's long-term vision.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
SupportiveJennifer Stewart ThurstonApr 16, 2026

Emphasized the value of raising youth on working farms and urged the commission to protect farmland from being permanently lost.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Apr 16, 2026 · 0:00 →
OpposedDennis PattersonJan 28, 2026

Voiced concerns about the Hancock rezone, arguing that the parcel has two dwellings and that mobile homes violate county code outside mobile home parks.

County Commission (11:30 A.M. Meeting) - Jan 28, 2026 · 34:40 →
OpposedJeff SinghDec 18, 2025

A nearby resident strongly opposed the rezone, arguing that the applicant brought in a trailer hooked illegally to another house's power and water, and that approving the rezone would reward bad behavior.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Dec 18, 2025 · 0:00 →
SupportiveMitch HancockDec 18, 2025

The applicant explained that dairy employees have lived on the property for years and that both homes have proper utilities, asking for the rezone to accommodate employee housing.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Dec 18, 2025 · 0:00 →
OpposedBrodie CalderOct 16, 2025

Submitted a formal written objection regarding lack of proper mailed notice for multiple family-owned parcels and requesting exclusion from the proposed AHZ rezone.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Oct 16, 2025 · 0:00 →
OpposedVance SmithOct 16, 2025

Submitted written comments expressing concerns that the rezone targets specific developers rather than genuine planning, and requested that Brookside Ranches and surrounding properties be left off the map.

Planning Commission (Regular) - Oct 16, 2025 · 0:00 →
OpposedDeAnna HardyJun 11, 2025

Spoke during general public comment criticizing community general plans, zoning boards, and new taxes like the transient room tax.

County Commission (Regular) - Jun 11, 2025 · 1:08:24 →
ConcernedDeanna HardyApr 23, 2025

Expressed concern regarding United Nations Agenda 2030, smart cities, property rights, and vehicle ownership restrictions.

County Commission (Regular) - Apr 23, 2025 · 1:02:19 →

News & external sources (10)

KSL TV

Paiute Tribe opposes Iron County's proposed zoning changes near tribal lands

Paiute Tribe opposes Iron County's proposed zoning changes near tribal lands

KSL TV

Why Salt Lake City wants to make it easier for second homes to be built on lots

Why Salt Lake City wants to make it easier for second homes to be built on lots

KSL TV

A popular Sugar House deli is relocating, but it needs a waiver to keep its current menu

A popular Sugar House deli is relocating, but it needs a waiver to keep its current menu

KSL TV

Proposed high-rise next to Salt Lake City historic church quietly fizzles

Proposed high-rise next to Salt Lake City historic church quietly fizzles

KSL TV

Commission OKs proposed tower at Sugar House Zions location, but not full height

Commission OKs proposed tower at Sugar House Zions location, but not full height

Cache Valley DailyOct 2, 2026

Ad hoc citizens' group urges North Logan residents to turn out in force for Oct. 14 meeting

NORTH LOGAN – An ad hoc group of concerned citizens is planning to pack the next meeting of the North Logan City Council to demonstrate their opposition to a rezone proposal they say threatens to overload schools, jeopardizes public safety and changes the character of a local neighborhood.

Herald Journal (Tremonton)Sep 23, 2026

PUD overlay request denied by Tremonton City Council

The most recent developer PUD overlay request made to the Tremonton City Council during its last meeting, held Sept. 15, was denied.It was the Heritage County Development Agreement, which has been presented aft...

Box Elder News JournalSep 9, 2026

Amid zoning designation controversy, county sets town hall meetings

Amid zoning designation controversy, county sets town hall meetings Box Elder News Journal

Herald Journal (Tremonton)Sep 9, 2026

PUD Overlay request denied in Tremonton

A denial of the Valley Vistas Planned Unit Development (PUD) Overlay request was voted on during the planning commission meeting Tuesday evening in Tremonton.The request was for the adjustment of the zoning, cu...

Box Elder News JournalSep 9, 2026

County gives home tattoo businesses the green light - Box Elder News Journal

Tattoo, body-art and piercing businesses may now qualify as home occupations in unincorporated Box Elder County under a code change approved Sept. 2 by the county commission. The change came through Ordinance 666, a number that immediately drew attention from Commission Chair Tyler Vincent. u201cCould we please change that number?u201d Vincent asked as Community Development Director Scott Lyons came forward <a href="https://www.benewsjournal.com/articles/county-gives-home-tattoo-businesses-the-green-light/">[…]</a>